ML# :3591133 Located on picturesque Old Harbor Road in the coveted seaside hamlet of New Suffolk, this irresistibly charming Dutch gambrel home was built by a master craftsman and lovingly referred to by the former owner as The Guest House. The residence features two ensuite bedrooms, three full baths, a sun-drenched dining room with a wood-burning fireplace, a large living room with an additional wood-burning fireplace, a cozy den with built-in shelving, and a beautiful screened-in porch. A single-story chef’s kitchen overlooks the yard, featuring a soaring vaulted ceiling and large French doors that open onto a generous bluestone patio. The property’s highlight is its magical grounds, which include a large in-ground gunite-heated saltwater pool, a handsome barn, and a professionally designed landscape with winding garden paths dotted with century-old trees, mature hollies, and vibrant hydrangeas. The result is a stunning green enclave that creates a private and enchanting setting. A sandy bay beach, Old Cove Yacht Club, and Shagwog Marina are just down the street. The property is two minutes from New Suffolk’s restaurants and business district and minutes to Cutchogue’s downtown.
650 Old Harbor Rd, New Suffolk, NY, 11956
ML# :3590758 New Suffolk, North Fork BAYFRONT residence. Ideal location to while away the hours and enjoy the North Fork farm-stands, wineries and more! Sublime Bayfront With Dock. Home Features quality, high-speed internet in Colonial Revival Charm at the beach... Entry Hall, Broad Waterside Living Room W/Fireplace and Views, formal dining room, Eik, Den/Br W/Bath and First Floor Master Suite W/Bath; Upstairs 2 Bedrooms and Bath. Private Estate Area minutes to all: North Fork Wineries, Farm-stands, Shopping and top-tier restaurants. Permit# 0139
199 Old Harbor Rd, New Suffolk, NY, 11956
ML# :3588876 Waterviews! An opportunity to live year-round in the charming waterside North Fork hamlet of New Suffolk. This fully furnished three bedroom, two bathroom home is just a block from the water and restaurants. Home features state of the art updated natural gas mechanicals. New washer and dryer. Huge den/office can double as a work from home space on first level. Rental Permit #0973
1250 2nd Street, New Suffolk, NY, 11956
ML# :3302005 Quintessential North Fork sandy bay beachfront rental. Stunning views across Cutchogue Harbor and Peconic Bay will be yours at this spacious waterfront home, whether from the airy great room, the brick patio, or from the beachside deck. Tucked away down a quiet drive, this home offers peace and privacy in historic New Suffolk. There are 3 bedrooms and 2 baths upstairs, one bedroom and one bath downstairs, a sitting room with fireplace, full kitchen with breakfast bar, and water views from almost every room.
1155 Old Harbor Rd, New Suffolk, NY, 11956
ML# :3185487 This classic updated 19th century home in the heart of historic New Suffolk is just 4 blocks to one of the North Fork’s best bay beaches, plus two renowned local restaurants. It offers stylish living spaces -- living room, den, dining room, eat-in kitchen, 3 bedrooms and 2 full baths, central air conditioning. Many antique details and original wood floors add to the charm. The wraparound porch invites lounging, as does the spacious backyard with shade trees. Available after September 2024.
640 Orchard Street, New Suffolk, NY, 11956
ML# :3103605 SEASONAL RENTAL available summer 2025. Just two blocks to a sandy bay beach, this charming 1-bedroom cedar shake cottage Is the perfect summer getaway. The bedroom has a queen size bed, the bathroom Is completely renovated. The living room has a futon sofa, and the spacious eat-in kitchen features full size appliances. A furnished brick patio runs the length of the cottage, complete with gas grill. Great value with utilities included. NOT available year-round. New Suffolk is a historic maritime hamlet at the heart of the North Fork, with two restaurants and great beaches. Moments from renowned wineries and farms.
16640 Main Street Unit Cottag, New Suffolk, NY, 11956
ML# :3513788 2025 Rates May 23-Sept 1 $65K, May 1-21 $5K, May 1-30, $10K, June 15K, July $23, 500, A1-LD $25K, 9/1-30 $7, 500, October $7, 500: Pristine Mid Century Modern Waterfront with 200’ Of Private Sugar Sand Beach! Property Features Breathtaking Views Of Robins Island, Southampton And Nassau Point. Chic Furnishings Adorn This Lovely Home Along with Interior Panoramic Views Of The Great Peconic Bay. Open Living Space with High Ceilings, Master Suite, 3 Additional Bedrooms, An Eat-In Kitchen And 2.5 Baths.
189 Old Harbor Rd, New Suffolk, NY, 11956
ML# :3470548 Looking for the perfect getaway? Look no further than this charming 3 bedroom, 2 bath seasonal rental, located just minutes away from everything you need to make your vacation unforgettable. With its prime location just a short walk from New Suffolk Beach, Legends restaurant, the New Suffolk Marina, and local wineries, golf, and farms, this rental is the perfect home base for all your adventures. Inside, this rental is spacious, comfortable, and filled with all the amenities you need for an stress-free stay. With three bedrooms, two baths, and plenty of space for everyone, there’s plenty of room to spread out and enjoy your vacation. And when it’s time to entertain, the back deck and yard are perfect for gathering. Available in Summer as well as the off-season. Rental Permit #: 0933
455 Fred Street, New Suffolk, NY, 11956